Discussion about this post

User's avatar
C Woody's avatar

Well written as always Lily. The time of complacency has certainly passed, people need to use their voices now, before they lose those voices forever.

Much appreciation for all your writing!

Expand full comment
Joe Van Steenbergen's avatar

I wish we had a chance to redeem Western Civilization, but the reality is, we don't, and we can't. I read "The Decline of the West" by Oswald Spengler some time ago. He published this work in about 1926. He traces the histories of the world's older civilizations and the reasons for their decline, and compares their trajectories with ours. Even in 1926 he was able to predict the fall of Western Civilization and, with what I think is pretty amazing prescience, suggest that the downward spiral would accelerate after 2000. Think about all that has happened in the last 24 years and see if you don't think his prediction was pretty close to the mark.

The one overriding theme of his work, and there have been others who suggest similar outcomes, is that the decline of the civilization is irreversible and inevitable. We may want to believe we have a chance to turn things around, but we're dreaming. The rot that affects our civilization has taken generations to set in; this stuff didn't change overnight. It stands to reason that any meaningful positive changes that might reverse this decline also would take generations to bear fruit. And, likely as not, this only would be possible after some cataclysmic event that affected huge swaths of the world's populations, something that would completely destroy existing institutions and thereby force us to start anew. Compare where we are now with where the Roman Empire was just before it collapsed. Rampant corruption, lack of moral standards, huge debts caused by endless wars and "bread and circuses" to pacify the masses, etc. Incremental changes will not happen and cannot make any meaningful difference to halt the decline. As you say, all we can do now is position ourselves to survive and take care of ourselves and our families and our closest friends.

It would be wonderful if all this were not true, but we don't live in the world of wonderful any more.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts