Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amy Sukwan's avatar

This is an excellent summary of the issue and I will be sharing it. Anytime an idea supercedes the individual, whether it's the notion of Appeasing the Sun Gods, Public Health, or Public Good, it must be understood that the individual will suffer at the behest of the individuals that created the idea to begin with. I've long favored all drug legalization, for example, not because I use drugs, but because if there is no victim, there is no crime. In short a junkie who steals from others to support his habit should be charged accordingly, as should a drunkard who beats his wife, say. Of course those indivual actions also have a consequence on that individual's body or ability, say, which they need to live with. A greta many atrocities have happened in the name of the greater good...

Expand full comment
NE - Naked Emperor Newsletter's avatar

The argument that society, as a concept, doesn't act or have a will of its own, but is rather a summary term for interactions among individuals, is a good one. The idea that certain entities often get to define 'the greater good' and enforce it on others highlights a need for constant vigilance. Also, the emphasis on individual rights as the foundation of freedom resonates with me (Hence my No 6 moniker!) - true freedom encapsulates each person's ability to pursue their well-being while respecting others' rights to do the same.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts