Discussion about this post

User's avatar
arrotsevni's avatar

You capture the Western society guilt complex perfectly. It is guilt assumed that is not deserved.

When global society was more tribal, several hundred years ago, we operated more using our limbic emotional responses based on basic survival needs. Now that societies have evolved from survival to stable living standards with more than adequate food and shelter, our perceptions have moved to, the far more contemplative and analytical, frontal lobes. Protections to free speech and individual property rights became paramount. Thoughts nearly unknown 1,000 years ago. This evolution began when the Dutch began to reclaim land from the sea, a truly inventive activity, and became the US Constitution after long development.

Those today who feel guilty of behavior by ancestors do not have a sense of how far humanity, and themselves as part, have traveled in our perceptions of others. That some feel guilt should be a trigger to see themselves as very different between themselves and their ancestors. They should not feel guilty. They should be proud to recognize they recognize the differences.

Expand full comment
Julian Tompsett's avatar

As always, an excellent essay Lily. You always manage to make me see things in a more rounded way. I have just started reading Hidden History, the secret origins of the first World War, an excellent book btw, and makes you question the British Empire, but we were not the first empire and won't be the last, and we today are not responsible for their actions.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts